I run a productivity consulting business. That's a fairly specific area of work: we don't maintain websites or treat cancer or sell lollipops. But these days, it seems like I'm coming across more and more businesses and jobseekers that try to claim to be all things to all people. I run across marketing companies that do sales training, employee satisfaction surveys and provide IT services. I find bookkeeping services that offer outsourced social media, copyediting, and inbound technical support. It seems the ongoing recession has inspired companies not only to do more with less, but to claim that they can do more in general.
This phenomenon reminds me of my favorite five dollar word: verisimilitude. It means "the appearance or semblance of truth." If you tell me that you're a heart surgeon, I'll take you at your word. But if you claim to also be a licensed attorney, a four-time divorcee, and member of generation Y, I won't believe you. Insisting that you have done all of these things lacks verisimilitude. It just doesn't sound true.
It's bad when companies claim that they do more than just one thing, but it's even worse when it comes from people looking for work. I know that you want to show a breath of experience and capacity, but if you tell me you can do anything I won't believe you can do any one thing well. You might believe that you are covering your bases, but really you are making yourself seem less trustworthy.
Whether you run a company or if you're looking to join one, consider the merits of focus. It's okay to have varied interests, but the more talents you claim to have the harder it is to believe you're the best. Work on your verisimilitude. Help others to know what you do.
Comment
Though it's a month old post have to remark how posts from such as Robbie continue to make SI what it is, informative and enjoyable time away from "work." Even for a retiree lol
"Jack of all trades and master of none," comes to mind here. General and broad experiences often serve well but not so much in today's professional world. Being a liberal arts oriented individual I saw this coming 40 years ago but being a newscaster/journalist in between air traffic control and elected state officeholder I realized the 8-5 retire with a gold watch thing just wasn't me so a lot of outside sales and promotional work followed.
I was 30 when I got my first calculator for Christmas and 50 buying a computer so Joomla, cloud computing and the computers on a cell phone are beyond even rocket science and brain surgery to me. Am building a independtly owned business axxociation which allows me to "fit" with experience as a Chambe rof Commerice exec and interact with humans and not a machine. But that's me and today's world demands most specialize not generalize. You view Gerry Dick' s "Inside Indiana Business" or similar programs and the lament of business executives interviewed is a constant bemoaning that today's job applicants are under-educated and thus under-quaified.
Me thinks they are saying they require skills not vefrsimilitude!
Comment by Robby Slaughter on November 2, 2011 at 11:51am Thanks, Rodger!
I don't want to discourage people from having goals. You could become a firefighter, but it would take many years of study and practice.
My concern is that people imply that they can do everything, which is just untrue. You can do anything, not everything. The point is to pick something.
Comment by Rodger D. Johnson on November 1, 2011 at 11:42pm
Comment by Robby Slaughter on October 22, 2011 at 1:48pm
Comment by Lisa Pellam on October 22, 2011 at 1:31pm 4 members
775 members
479 members
373 members
57 members
Started by Andrea Lollar in Non Profit: events, news, ideas 8 hours ago.
Started by Jamar Cobb-Dennard in Classifieds - Help Wanted 10 hours ago.
Started by Michael E Conner in Business on Friday.
Started by Michael E Conner in Non Profit: events, news, ideas on Friday.
Started by John Farinacci in Marketing, advertising and branding May 10.
Started by Marita Topmiller in Non Profit: events, news, ideas May 1.
Started by Andrea Bills in Business. Last reply by Andrea Bills Apr 28.
Started by Jamar Cobb-Dennard in Classifieds - Help Wanted. Last reply by Ryan E. McCormick Apr 24.
Started by Jamar Cobb-Dennard in Classifieds - Help Wanted Apr 20.
Started by Leanne Miller in Classifieds - Intern Exchange Apr 19.
© 2012 Created by Pat Coyle.
You need to be a member of Smaller Indiana to add comments!
Join Smaller Indiana