Smaller Indiana

Making people and ideas findable

Mike Magan

The business of religion: are demographics driving church relocations?

My little corner of Southwest carmel is beginning to look like a mini-Jerusalem.

Within the area of 106th Street to the South, Michigan Road to the west 116th St to the north and Towne(Township Line) to the east, there are three religious congregations building a sanctuary. These are actually joining three churches that already exist in this rectangular area.

Perhaps the most fascinating thing to me is that Holy Trinity Greek Orthodox Church, which is building a Byzantine-style facility with an amazing golden dome as well as Congregation Shaarey Tefilla, which just completed its synagogue off 116th and Towne are actually re-locating from central Indianapolis.

As someone who thought congregations are composed of the people who live within a certain diameter around its worship space, what is happening here? Are the congregations moving with the buildings, or are the buildings relocated to be closer to its people? Another way to put the question, what’s driving these transplantations? Size or demographics?

According to Holy Trinity’s website, it is a parish that has been on a journey for over 90 years. Founded by immigrants who had journeyed themselves to this country, the parish’s first temple was on west 16th Street. By 1961, the Holy Trinity parish had outgrown those facilities and moved to our present location at 40th and Pennsylvania Streets.

Church officials claim they have again outgrown their facilities, home of the well-known Greek Festival in September. Holy Trinity purchased twenty acres in 2001 at the NE corner of 106th and Shelborne and has spent the last two years building its Byzantine-style temple. It’s really cool on a sunny day since it features a unique dome that reminds me of the Golden Dome atop Notre Dame’s Main Building.

The reason I ask about demographics is that my church, St. Monica is undergoing its second dramatic population shift in less than 20 years. The parish welcomed the rapid influx of young families as Pike township families filed into new apartment and track home developments in the 1980s and 1990s. I’ve seen many, mostly “anglo” families moving to Carmel, Zionsville Avon and Fishers as we’ve seen a huge increase in Hispanic families.

Does your church look like it did 10 or 15 years ago? Do you think these congregations are moving for space reasons or because its leaders discovered so many of its flock were moving north as well?

Tags: church, demographics, festival, greek

2 Comments

Theresia Whitfield Comment by Theresia Whitfield on June 29, 2008 at 2:50pm
Interesting points, Mike. I think many of the churches are heading north because that's where the people are. Part of it could be that they're trying to keep up with their membership but I also tend to think that they're trying to reach out to other non-churched folks. That's not to suggest that most non-churched folks are moving north. There just happens to be more people heading north so that's where they're "marketing" their efforts, if you will.

I also think part of the issue stems from a spacial issue. I've seen smaller churches who have outgrown their buildings try to build on the small property they've got, and it usually doesn't go so well and growth becomes stagnant. My old church from back home did that. They moved out of the area because they had run out of room and needed more space if they wanted to accommodate for parking and additional growth.

So, it may be a combination of the two but it's interesting none-the-less.
Erik Deckers Comment by Erik Deckers on June 30, 2008 at 9:18am
Maybe I'm a little more cynical than Theresia, but I think they're following the money. The north side of Indy has the most money, and as a result, the churches up there have a lot of money themselves.

I also agree with her that it is a matter of space. If you head up into the Noblesville area, there is still a lot of room to build big giant churches. Trying to build one of those in Broad Ripple or Downtown would be nearly impossible.

Add a Comment

You need to be a member of Smaller Indiana to add comments!

Join this network

RSS

Forum

Greg Clements

New Career Opportunity

I have recently moved from Fort Wayne to Indy, gotten settled in, and have begun to search for a new career. My back ground includes B2B sales, account management, marketing, advertising, inside sa...

Started by Greg Clements in Classifieds - Position Wanted 8 hours ago.

D. L. Russell

New Issue of Strange, Weird, and Wonderful Magazine out now!

Just wanted to ask everyone to visit www.strangeweirdandwonderful.com for the latest issue of Strange, Weird, and Wonderful Magazine. Matthew Sideman, Jeff Somers, Dina Leacock, Joel Arnold, Mary ...

Started by D. L. Russell in Classifieds - blatant self promotion 12 hours ago.

D. L. Russell

Things I've Learned as an Adult....

1. Just because you're right, doesn't mean people will want to do things your way. 2. Bad Behavior really does make bad law. 3. Democrats on the "Far-Left" are wackos, but because those in the ce...

Started by D. L. Russell in Questions and Answers 19 hours ago.

Pat Coyle

Why is learning history important to the future of American culture? 7 Replies

We spend millions of dollars building museums and teaching history in schools, but does our contemporary American culture truly value its history? Based on our American understanding, appreciation...

Started by Pat Coyle in Education. Last reply by Nancy Conner 8 hours ago.

Nicki Laycoax

I need a mannequin 9 Replies

Does anyone have a mannequin I can borrow in the Indy area for about a week?

Tagged: mannequin, borrow

Started by Nicki Laycoax in Questions and Answers. Last reply by Nicki Laycoax 8 hours ago.

Nicki Laycoax

Office Furniture 4 Replies

Where do you purchase your office furniture? Are you satisfied with the products and their service? Why did you choose to buy from the store you buy from? Did you buy online?

Tagged: stores, buying, furniture, office

Started by Nicki Laycoax in Questions and Answers. Last reply by Michelle Treloar 9 hours ago.

Cissi Sherlock

Reach Out! Out Reach - Gathering Area Food Pantry Information 1 Reply

I am gathering information on Food pantries in Indianapolis and surrounding areas. Please HELP me by providing information on any that you know of. If your church, business or organization provides...

Started by Cissi Sherlock in Classifieds - blatant self promotion. Last reply by Amy Magan 2 hours ago.

Stacey R. Davis

Need a location for a fund raiser to benefit YSC 9 Replies

October is Breast Cancer Awareness month. Davis Designs is organizing an event to raise money for Young Survivors Coalition. The event is called Pink Drink happy hour. I prefer Thursday Oct 23 7-9,...

Started by Stacey R. Davis in Events: Fundraisers / NPO. Last reply by Scott Sutherland 6 hours ago.

Kyle Lacy

Learn How To Grow Your Business by Blogging! 2 Replies

Have you wanted to learn how to blog? Would you like to know how to use blogging to build visibility and business? I am teaching a class through Rainmaker Universitycalled Grow Your Business By Blo...

Started by Kyle Lacy in Events for the creative class. Last reply by Kyle Lacy 19 hours ago.

Pat Coyle

Is it time to add classifieds to SI? 14 Replies

Is it time to ban blatant self-promotion? Flickr Lately we have seen an uptick in job seekers, job postings and blatant self-promotion on our Forum. And we continue to see the Forum used to promo...

Started by Pat Coyle in Questions and Answers. Last reply by Wil Green 10 hours ago.

About Smaller Indiana

Pat Coyle Pat Coyle created this social network on Ning.

© 2008   Created by Pat Coyle

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Privacy  |  Terms of Service